Tropa de Elite / Elite Squad – In Praise of Police Violence to Please Upper-Class Brazilians
Arts & Entertainment → Television / Movies
- Author Yugo Kabeya
- Published April 15, 2008
- Word count 678
The past few days have split up public opinion in regards to the acclaimed "Tropa de Elite" (Elite Squad) movie by director José Padilha, which got its upmost peak of fame abroad upon receiving an internationally renowned award, Berlin Festival Golden Bear.
In reality, what does not seem clear to international audience lies on the fact that the awarded movie is a piece of propaganda when it comes to conveying the idea that Rio de Janeiro’s police force is focused on "trying" to be honest and incorruptible.
There cannot be honesty when money talks. And money talks big time when Rio de Janeiro’s police gets full awareness of the fact that drug money wills and deals big time at the Favelas located in that city, which openly corrupts its police force as the local media attests everyday.
The corruption that happens in Rio de Janeiro as well as other major cities in Brazil is a widely known fact to most upper-middle class in the country, which chooses to ignore its existence.
Drug is an income source in a country where most African descendents are harmed by a silent Apartheid. It is a social problem that most likely should be healed with jobs and education. But the Brazilian elite would rather suppress the problem, rather than solving it through income distribution.
It is not only full-grown man involved in the drug traffic. Small children are allured to criminality. The children accept because of the money they can make, but unfortunately, some are threatened with death, if they do not work for the organized crime. The organized crime has deep roots in the favelas' families. It is not a "police gets bandit" case anymore, people non-committed to the crime (women and children as well) are compulsorily drawn to the traffic because the drug barons reign inside the Favelas.
The BOPE elite squad shown in the film makes use of outright violence and sophisticated torture methods. The message therein is that as the squad is composed of the good guys, this type of violence, in disregard of human rights, is to be appraised and condoned. In fact, human rights are a concept which is regarded as an obstruction to law enforcement by the social elite in Brazil. The usual discourse of such elite, is that a "good bandit, is a dead bandit", or that "human rights exists only for bandits" and not for the taxpayers.
It is a wide belief among the extreme right in Brazil that if they could they would remove poverty by removing the poor. As the upper-middle class is increasingly cornered by the violence ushered by the drug traffickers, there are more and more people becoming sympathizers of the extermination of the poor so that they can drive their luxurious cars in style along their fancy Boulevards. That would be a quick and effective way to make that dream come true.
Many are conniving to the extermination of the poor, but none dares to say it openly for they fear organized crime might retaliate.
In a media-oligarchy ruled country, the view exposed in "Tropa de Elite" (60% of the film casting was supplied by Globo TV Network), will most likely to become the prevalent view about the issue in the country. On one side, there lies the upper-middle class luxury-minded culture (a culture which was vastly spread by Globo Network), and on the other, the world of the un-possessed and unemployed people in Favelas, that live on a culture of violence, crime, homicide and alike to feed their self-esteem.
By not being able to reach the ideal luxury world portrayed by the Globo Network soap-operas by means of employment and social integration, the lower strata is up to get what they want, by the use of force.
Brief and to the Point:
If Brazil spent years years looking for its National Hero, a truculent Capitão Nascimento has just been elected the Middle Upper Class Hero, the true Saviour of the World in flesh and blood, the one who catters for the well-off "Tired Ones" (Cansados).
Political Scientist, Historian and Anthropologist.
Has extensively travelled Asia.
http://briefandtothepoint.blogspot.com/
Article source: https://articlebiz.comRate article
Article comments
There are no posted comments.
Related articles
- When Detail Becomes the Story: Macro Lenses in Narrative and Commercial Filmmaking
- “The Man of Steel’s Tragic Fall: The Life and Times of George Reeves.”
- “The Quiet Comeback: Brendan Fraser’s Journey from Stardom to Shadows and Back Again.”
- “Ashes of the Heart.”
- “Light, Time, and Suffering: The Cinematic Ordeal of The Revenant.”
- “Breaking the Frame: How Independent Cinema Redefined Hollywood from the Margins.”
- “The Elusive Muse: Greta Garbo and the Art of Disappearing.”
- “Dream Logic and Cinematic Reality.”
- “Glamour, Blood, and the Spotlight: Lana Turner, Johnny Stompanato, and Hollywood’s Most Notorious Scandal.”
- “Blood, Dust, and Honor: How “The Wild Bunch” Shattered the Western Myth.”
- “Dean Martin: From Small-Town Beginnings to Timeless Legend of Music and Film.”
- “Daniel Day-Lewis— Deep Immersion and Subtle Gesture in There Will Be Blood.”
- “Shadows of Youth: How The Graduate Still Echoes Across a Lifetime.”
- "Louise Brooks: The Icon Who Defied Hollywood."
- “Play It Again, World: Why Casablanca Still Speaks to Us All These Years Later.”
- “From Spotlight to Parliament: The Fearless Journey of Glenda Jackson.”
- “Drifting Rooms and Vanishing Faces: Confronting the Abyss in The Father.”
- Mastering Cinematic Camera Movement: The Art and Science of Fluid Heads
- "Grace Beyond Glamour: Audrey Hepburn's Timeless Reign in a World of Glitter and Excess."
- “The Relentless Ascent of Tom Cruise: Hollywood’s Tireless Risk-Taker.”
- “Shadows and Smoke: The Seductive Descent of Film Noir.”
- Indie Film Hack: How a Used Master Prime 50 mm Creates $1-Million Visuals
- “Godfather to Guardian: Al Pacino’s Journey to Redemption in Scent of a Woman.”
- “The Man of Steel’s Tragic Fall: The Life and Times of George Reeves.”
- “Shadowland: The Tragic Ordeal of Frances Farmer and the Machinery That Broke Her.”
- “Glenn Ford: Hollywood’s Reluctant Heartthrob Who Played by His Own Rules.”
- “From Navy Tough Guy to Hollywood Everyman: The Life and Legacy of Ernest Borgnine.”
- Used Master Prime Inspection: 5 Critical Checks to Avoid Refurbished Scams
- “Wounds That Time Couldn’t Heal: Watching The Best Years of Our Lives Through the Lens of Memory and Mourning.”
- “Mira Sorvino: From Oscar Glory to Hollywood Silence.”