Medical Errors, Mistakes and Misadventures: "What We Have Here Is A Failure To Communicate"
- Author Moshe Sharon
- Published August 17, 2010
- Word count 960
The Institute of Medicine Identifies "Health Illiteracy" as a Root Cause of Medical Error
The Institute of Medicine (IOM) issued a report on April 8, 2004 [IOM Health Literacy: A Prescription to End Confusion] stating that as many as 90 million American adults lack the reading and math skills needed to understand basic health information and navigate the U.S. healthcare system. The IOM identified a conceptual entity with their new title called "Health Literacy: a prescription to end confusion".
The IOM report specified that the list of skills required for a U.S. citizen to be health literate are reading, writing, listening, speaking, arithmetic, and conceptual knowledge. The IOM defined health literacy as "the degree to which individuals have the capacity to obtain, process, and understand basic information and services needed to make appropriate decisions regarding their health." At some point, most individuals – even the well educated with strong reading and writing skills – encounter some health information regarding forms, a drug or a procedure that they don’t understand. Aside from calling for the health care system to address the problem through improved health education, the IOM put the onus on physicians and other health care providers to listen to their patients to discern whether they have understood what they needed to know to participate in their disease management and/or improve their health status with preventive measures.
In my professional experience I have encountered thousands of patients in the home environment over two decades. Most of the people I interviewed who were on medications did not know the names of their drugs, or the potential side-effects. All they knew for the most part was the color, shape and what disease it was for (i.e. high blood pressure, diabetes, nervousness or infection)
There are two basic areas of concern in the IOM report. The first one is public awareness of where to go for which problems. This is a matter of public education and deals with the population before they enter the system and encounter a health provider. The second area of concern is the information provided by the physician or other health practitioner. This applies to individuals who are under the care of the particular health provider, be it a physician, nurse practitioner, chiropractor, H.M.O., home infusion company, etc. The IOM attributes the failure to ensure that patients understand enough to participate in their own care as a major cause of medical mistakes.
Therefore, part of the duty that a licensed health practitioner owes is to make certain that patient or responsible party understands the information that must be provided to the extent that the patient or significant other can participate in managing the illness and engage in preventive measures.
Case in point 1:
In the first case, a man living in the USA who was not proficient in English received a prescription for Tylenol with codeine. The label read: "1 or 2 tablets every 3 hours as needed for pain". The patient understood this to mean that he could take two tablets every 3 hours or more often as needed. He ended taking two tablets every hour until he collapsed from a narcotic overdose. He survived with a mild degree of anoxic encephalopathy (brain damage from lack of oxygen). The patient sued contending that it would have been a simple matter to ask the patient, "What is your understanding of the instruction regarding your pain pills?" and not doing so was unreasonable.
Although many would argue that people must take responsibility for misunderstanding simple directions, the IOM points out that approximately ninety million people in America are unable to understand medical directions as provided on labels, instructions and verbally. On the other hand, one can also argue that people know whether they understand something or not and if not, they still have the responsibility of asking for further explanation. However, the core of the problem in poor communication is not lack of understanding but misunderstanding. Health-illiterate patients most often walk away from a consultation not realizing that they have an erroneous set of instructions in mind that differs from what the health practitioner said.
Therefore, it is incumbent upon the health care provider to take a reasonable step to be certain that the patient received and understood the medical advice correctly. Additionally we need to take a look at the standard instructions such as "take one or two tablets every three hours as needed for pain" and perhaps change it to "take one or two tablets every three hours or less often as needed for pain."
Case in Point 2
The second case involves a 63-year-old man who was sent home from the hospital on intravenous Morphine delivered via patient controlled analgesia (PCA). The man died of an overdose on the second day of the infusion despite the fact that his wife was checking on him frequently through the whole time. In the investigation that followed, it was apparent from the records that the home infusion intake nurse failed to provide sufficient teaching to the patient’s wife. The wife simply looked at her husband, who was asleep most of the time, and thought he was okay because he was breathing and sleeping peacefully. She obviously did not possess enough health literacy to check for narcotic stupor by waking him up and seeing whether he was difficult to arouse. She needed to find out whether he could respond to voice, or required tactile or even painful stimulation to wake up. The nurse needed to make certain that the wife understood how to assess level of consciousness. It is likely that with a few extra moments of effective communication, the wife would have been able to know that her husband was in trouble and she would have dialed 911 soon enough to save his life.
Moshe Sharon has been a registered nurse for 31 years with a graduate degree and specialty in public health. He has spent most his career in search of ways to achieve true healing for those who are not yet well. He has studied and practiced holistic health care for two decades, always believing in the inseparability of the mind, body and spirit.
Article source: https://articlebiz.comRate article
Article comments
There are no posted comments.
Related articles
- Bohemian Farmhouse Luxury: Elevating Interiors with Carved Statement Pieces
- The Fusion of Old World Philosophies and Modern Opulence
- Modern Boho Interior Design: A Fusion of Creativity and Elegance
- The Top Ways to Use PLR Content Effectively for Your Business
- The Ultimate Guide to Hiring a Private Chauffeur Service in Cape Town
- NFPA 96 Compliance and Hood Cleaning: Captive Aire Hood vs. Accurex Hoods, Greenheck Systems
- Fire Suppression Systems in NYC: How to Stay FDNY, DOB & NFPA 96 Compliant
- A Guide to Taking Care of your Pet Guinea Pig
- Used 25-Passenger Bus for Sale | High-Quality and Affordable
- Artisanal Carved Statement Doors: Luxury Aesthetic
- Essex Roofs Under Siege: Battling Moss, Grime, and the British Weather with Rayleigh Gutter Cleaning and Repairs
- Coaster Mini Bus for Sale | Reliable & Affordable Options
- Take Control of Your Health with Advanced Testing
- Plastic Injection Moulding In The Medical Industry: Precision And Sterility
- Behind the Scenes
- Enhancing Wine Storage with Mogul Interior Sideboards, Credenzas, and Antique Armoires
- The Power of Gratitude for a Healthier, Happier Life
- Serene Reading Nooks: Infusing Elegance and Comfort into Your Home
- Sedation Dentistry 101: Answers to Your Most Common Questions
- Whimsical Gallery Walls: Mogul Interior Carved Wall Panels
- From Chandeliers to Pendants: How Can You Find Your Perfect Lighting at Fehmi Lights?
- Closing the Gaps in Business Central: Elevating Warehouse and Inventory Management
- Top 10 Stylish Kitchen Bar Tables in the UK for Every Home
- How to Reduce Mental Load and Enhance Well-being with Lenormand Cards
- Meet Sam Lang
- Why a Car Needs a Regular Service
- Web Design Agency in Singapore
- Is It Time to Leave Home? How to Find Your First Office
- Illuminate Your Home and Garden with Glow-in-the-Dark Products
- How Carbon Levels Influence the Properties of Carbon Steel Castings