Insurance and family values
- Author Marcus Stalder
- Published May 5, 2011
- Word count 529
In the majority of health plans offered to employees of cities and states, benefits are payable to dependents. There's an interesting federal case working its way through the court system at present. It arises from El Paso where a radical Christian organization managed to get an ordinance approved by the voters in the last election. As background, this organization thinks homosexuality is an abomination but, instead of openly framing the ordinance to target gays, the wording was designed up uphold "traditional family values". Thus, health coverage was only to be made available to those employed by the city, their spouses and dependent children. So instead of penalizing a small number of gay partners, this swept up hundreds of individuals whether as seniors or grandchildren. State law actually has provisions to protect the elderly who are dependent and those who have retired. Nevertheless, the city felt it was obliged by the ordinance to refuse benefits to anyone not an actual employee, a spouse or their dependent children. This sparked a very public argument between the city and the religious organization promoting the ordinance, but the organization refused to amend the wording or to assist the city in drafting a different version of the wording to limit its scope. For some reason, the religious leaders thought their intention clear in the wording and attacked the city as perverse in reading it as affecting hundreds of "other" people.
When warning notices terminating cover were sent out to some local judges, the President of the Police Association and other influential individuals, there was an immediate reaction in filing this case. A federal judge has now issued an injunction to restrain the city from implementing the ordinance pending a full hearing. The city, of course, has not defended the ordinance. It is on record as believing the wording of the ordinance to be discriminatory. Curiously, when the religious organisation tried to file a brief to support the ordinance, the judge ruled it had no standing to be a party. It will, however, be allowed to present arguments as a "friend of the court".
What it all boils down to is a simple test. To be enforceable, the ordinance must fulfill a genuine public purpose, particularly because this will force the city to break the contract with the health insurer. It should be said that if the voters thought they were saving the city money and were reducing the deficit, the ordinance could deliver a legitimate public benefit except the city's deficit is not that bad.
Putting this into a broader context, many cities are now finding themselves in similar difficulties with family values being used as an overall justification for cutting benefits to those not formally married. The Christian Right is on the march. So, when it comes to city health insurance plans, many equality groups are warming up proposals for the next round of elections. They are all aiming to outlaw any form of discrimination on the grounds of age, disability, marital status, sexual orientation, and so on when it comes to all aspects of health insurance coverage. It could all be building to some interesting city elections particularly in the southern states.
Sites like [http://www.hiinetwork.com/health-insurance-plans.html](http://www.hiinetwork.com/health-insurance-plans.html) let Marcus Stalder help people around the world in understanding and learning more about the subject. See what Marcus Stalder has written for the site here.
Article source: https://articlebiz.comRate article
Article comments
There are no posted comments.
Related articles
- The Pseudoscience of Reflexology: Fact or Fiction?
- Choosing the Right Wound Dressing: Foam, Hydrocolloid, and Alginate
- Charlie Chaplin: The Silent Genius Who Spoke to the World.
- Custom Domain Landing Page
- Christian Counseling A Unique Approach to Counseling
- Should You Do an Executive MBA After BBA Explained
- BBA Students Who Launched Million-Dollar Startups!
- Avatar: The Cinematic Revolution That Redefined Hollywood.
- How Does the U.S. Black Women’s Chamber of Commerce (USBWCC) Empower Black Women Entrepreneurs?
- Free Test Management Tools: Top Picks for QA 2025
- How to Get Placed FAST After BBA! Must-Know Tips!
- Exploring the Effectiveness of Magnetic Insoles
- The Top 5 Industries That Hire BBA Graduates
- How to Build a Personal Brand as a BBA Student!
- Wellness for Athletes
- Michael Mann: The Architect of Grit and Grandeur.
- Don't Risk A Gray Divorce!
- Mental Toughness Exercises
- No IIT? No Problem! BBA Can Get You Top Corporate Jobs!
- Can BBA Make You a Successful Business Leader?
- The Secret to Climbing the Corporate Ladder with BBA!
- Tyrone Power: The Dashing Leading Man Who Conquered Hollywood.
- Empowering Black Women Entrepreneurs: Inside the United States Black Women’s Chamber of Commerce
- Why Is Fehmi Lights Your Go-To Lighting Store Near Me in Brampton & Mississauga for Stylish Fixtures?
- No CAT? No Problem: Your Guide to MBA/PGDM Colleges in Hyderabad Without a CAT Score
- No CAT? No Problem: Your Guide to MBA/PGDM Colleges in Gurgaon Without a CAT Score
- No CAT? No Problem: Your Guide to MBA/PGDM Colleges in Noida Without a CAT Score
- The Relentless Passion of Al Pacino: From Stage Struggles to Cinematic Greatness.
- Weddings, Wineries, and Waterfronts: The Versatility of a Chauffeur in Victoria
- No CAT? No Problem: You’re Guide to MBA/PGDM Colleges in Mumbai Without a CAT Score