Making Sense of Miranda vs. Arizona
- Author Michael Dye
- Published May 30, 2012
- Word count 389
There is a fundamental misconception of what "Miranda warnings" are and when an officer must inform an arrested individual of his or her "Miranda Rights." Being a criminal defense attorney it is a guarantee that somebody will come into my office, at the least once a month, and tell me that the charges against them need to be dismissed since the arresting officer did not inform my client of his or her "Miranda rights" at the time of arrest. There is a look of shock on my clients face when I inform him "the officer did not have to give you Miranda warnings." In the public eye the misconception is so great that I have had potential clients not hire me because they refuse to believe that an officer does not need to read an individual's rights each time that the officer arrests somebody.
In the case of Miranda vs. Arizona the Untied States Supreme Court held that "in custody interrogation is inherently coercive." The court held further that so as to make sure that all statements by an individuals in custody were of their own free will, the Supreme Court held that a person who is in custody has to be advised of certain rights. The Miranda decision does not simply parrot the 5th Amendment, rather it states that an individual must be informed of certain rights, including 5th Amendment rights, when being questioned while in custody.
So there are two requirements that must be met before an officer must advise an arrestee of his or her Miranda warnings. The 1st requirement is that an individual has to be in custody. The 2nd requirement is that there must be questioning. Both must be present before Miranda warnings are required.
In case you are arrested and not questioned, the arresting officer does not have to advise you of your Miranda rights. If the officer questions you before you are taken into custody, the officer does not have to advise you of your Miranda rights. In the end, the remedy for a 5th Amendment violation is not to dismiss the case, but rather to suppress any statement which was subject to custodial interrogation without the benefit of Miranda warnings. However, many times, the suppression of a statement will eliminate much of the State's evidence and sometimes contributes to a dismissal.
The Law Offices of Michael A. Dye, P.A. is a criminal defense law firm in Broward County, Florida. Mr. Dye represents individuals charged with DUI, Drug Charges and other serious criminal offenses. For more information, please contact (954)745-9848 or visit www.AlcoholAndDrugLaw.comArticle source: http://articlebiz.com
There are no posted comments.
- How to Calculate Child Support
- Reason To Pursue A Personal Injury Case
- Divorce Lawyer/Attorney to Take Care of Your Divorce/Dissolution of Marriage
- The LA Criminal Defense Law Firm
- Let Trump keep looking at H-1Bs; there is a much better option for immigrants
- The Difference Between Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 Bankruptcy
- Forged Documents, Counterfeit Goods, Cyber Intrusion Including Identity Theft Have Become a Symbol Of Our 21st Century Culture
- Restrictions on some professions when striking
- Finding a Handwriting Expert in Canada or Handwriting Analyst is Tricky, Here's What To Look For
- A Fail-Proof Formula to Escape Drug Charges with Finest Drug Crime Lawyer
- Bike Safety Month: Tips for Cyclists and Motorists
- Covid-19 Update On Credit Cards Payment In UAE
- Know the Role of Criminal Defense Lawyer in Singapore
- Covid-19 Impact On Rental Contracts In UAE
- Impact on Working Hours during Ramadan Due to Covid-19
- All that you should know about the New Anti-Money Laundering Law
- Can Impact of Coronavirus be a Force Majeure Event?
- Multiculturalism here in Australia – a Good read for Migrants.
- How to Hire the Right Personal Injury Lawyer
- UAE joins nations monitoring Offenders through Electronic Tagging
- With the new Law in the UAE, the Prosecution Can Allow the Accused and the Victim to Settle Criminal Matters Amicably.
- Good Bye to Entangling Investigations, Minor Crimes to be Disposed within One Day in the UAE.
- Measures of UAE Ministry Of Labor To Curb Spread Of Coronavirus
- Worker's Compensation Law
- Can Employment Tribunal Cases Be Joined Together?
- Essential Factors to Consider Before Hiring German Translation Services
- 4 Signs You Need Cleaning Services
- Common Causes of Construction Site Accidents
- Preparing for an M&A